The stock for investor-owned companies may be closely held by owner-operators. As such, the optimal corporate structure considers the company’s tax liabilities as well as those of its owners.
If currently structured as a C corporation, the company might benefit from a transition to an S corporation. Income from a C corporation gets taxed twice before landing in the shareholders’ hands. Corporate tax rates apply to the company’s net income, and individual tax rates apply to each individual’s corporate dividends. By contrast, income from an S corporation only gets taxed once on each shareholder’s tax return. S corporations may deliver favorable tax treatment by leveraging cash accounting instead of accrual accounting. Also, sales of appreciated assets can create significant tax implications when the gain is locked inside a C corporation.
On the other hand, when key employees prove crucial to the health and long-term viability of the company, owner-operators may opt to grant stock options to motivate performance excellence and instill loyalty. A C corp is a natural structure for this arrangement. The bottom line results associated with having the right people in the right jobs may outweigh the potential tax savings of transitioning to an S corp.
If the majority shareholders are nearing retirement, they may want to liquidate holdings to fund their golden years. Based on how long they’ve owned their stock and the means through which it was acquired, it may be helpful for them to maintain the C corp status until they no longer have an interest in the company.
Owner-operators may also wish to consider the impact of the corporate structure on their estate plans. Some may wish to find a tax-efficient way to transfer ownership to their heirs. Others may have complex designs for the disposition of their residual estate.
At the end of the day, the decision comes down to a spirited discussion of the company and owner’s current positions and future plans. The sooner decisions are made, the easier it will be to adjust the corporate structure and take advantage of tax savings.