The distinction between personal and business goodwill can be critical in the context of a business sale. C corporations that sell their assets are subject to double taxation on the proceeds (once at the corporate level and again when the proceeds are distributed to shareholders). S corporations that began as C corporations are also subject to double taxation on built-in gains — unrealized appreciation on assets owned at the time of the conversion — if those assets, sold in 2017, are sold within the recognition period of five years after electing S status. Under the PATH Act passed by Congress on December 18, 2015, the five-year recognition period was made permanent.
Whether your construction business is a C corporation or an S corporation with built-in gains tax exposure, the impact of double taxation is reduced to the extent the company’s value is attributable to personal goodwill. Why? Because personal goodwill is considered the property of the individual owners, not the company, so it escapes taxation at the corporate level.
The value attributable to personal goodwill varies from company to company. Generally, the more a business relies on its owners’ talents, knowledge, reputation and relationships, the greater the value of personal goodwill. Keep in mind that, if owners sign employment or non-compete agreements, they may be deemed to have transferred their personal goodwill to the company, exposing it to corporate tax.